Board of Directors

Main Street Bank 'MSBC'

Main Street Financial Services Corp. 'MSFS'

• Mark Witmer

  
  Executive Chair (MSFS, MSBC) Director since 2021 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. Witmer has approximately 30 years of community banking experience, including commercial lending, agricultural lending and mortgage banking. Most recently Mr. Witmer served as Senior Executive Vice President and Chief Banking Officer of The Farmers National Bank of Canfield. Mr. Witmer served as the Chief Executive Officer of First National Bank of Orrville prior to the merger with The Farmers National Bank of Canfield.

• Jonathan Ciccotelli

  
  Vice Chair (MSFS, MSBC) Director since 2010 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. Ciccotelli is a Vice President in the Tax Services Group in the Wooster, Ohio office of Meaden and Moore, Ltd. and has been employed in such capacity since 2002. He is a Certified Public Accountant and has over 25 years of taxation work experience with large public accounting firms and has worked with publicly traded companies. Mr. Ciccotelli has been involved in community and economic development activities in Main Street Bank’ market area and serves as Chairman of the Company’s Audit Committee.

• Lance J. Ciroli

  
  Director since 2022 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. Ciroli was employed with the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), U.S. Treasury for 33 years.  At the time of his retirement from the OCC in 2008, Mr. Ciroli was the Assistant Deputy Comptroller heading up both the Cleveland, Ohio and Detroit, Michigan offices for the OCC.  Although currently inactive in the consulting business, Mr. Ciroli also co-founded NBE Consulting Services which provides consulting services to community banks.  Mr. Ciroli joined the Board of Directors of Farmers National Bank in Canfield, Ohio, in October 2010.  He then served as the Chairman of Farmers from October 2011 until his retirement in April 2021.  Mr. Ciroli provides the board with extensive experience in the banking industry and regulatory expertise.

• David L. Lehman

  
  Director since 2012 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. Lehman served as the President and CEO for the Company from December 2016 to August 2017. He is also a director of the Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company in Orrville, Ohio, where he was President of the company from 1990 through February 2016. Mr. Lehman has over 30 years of experience in the financial services industry and over 25 years leading a growing insurance company, and has been extensively involved in community and leadership development activities in Main Street Bank’s market area.

• Debra A. Marthey

  
  Director since 2011 (MSFS, MSBC) Ms. Marthey served as the Vice President and Treasurer for The J.M. Smucker Company in Orrville, Ohio with more than 35 years in various finance roles at the company. As Vice President and Treasurer for over 15 years, she managed the company’s liquidity resources, formulating and implementing the appropriate capital structure, corporate investment management, debt structure and management, and banking relationships with commercial banks. She also had responsibility for the company’s risk and insurance function and the management of the company’s retirement assets and 401(k) employee plans. Ms. Marthey has been involved in community and professional organizations in Main Street Bank’s market area.

• Glenn W. Miller

  
  Director since 2012 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. Miller is President and Chief Executive Officer of Holmes-Wayne Electric Cooperative in Millersburg, Ohio and has been employed in such capacity since 2004. He is also a Certified Public Accountant. Mr. Miller has over 25 years of experience in business management and financial statement preparation. Mr. Miller has been involved in community and economic development activities, including work in the oil and gas industry, in Main Street Bank’s market area.

• James "Jay" R. VanSickle II

  
  President and CEO (MSFS, MSBC) Director since 2017 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. VanSickle currently serves as the President and CEO for the Company. He is a Certified Public Accountant and has over 25 years of experience in the financial services industry. Prior to joining the Company, Mr. VanSickle served in senior management roles with Farmers National Bank of Canfield as Senior Vice President and Chief Risk Officer, and National Bancshares Corporation of Orrville as Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Mr. VanSickle is extensively involved in the community, serving as a board member on the Wooster All-Sports Booster Club and Wooster City School’s Business Advisory Council.

• Brian Hopkins

  
  Director since 2017 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. Hopkins is a Managing Director and partner of Ancora Holdings, Inc., an investment management and family wealth advisory firm based in Cleveland, Ohio. Mr. Hopkins joined the firm in 2003 and was the second partner of Ancora. He has been an integral part of a team that has grown the firm from $50 million in assets under management at inception in 2003 to $6.3 billion in assets under management today. Mr. Hopkins founded the firm’s hedge fund practice and continues to be a portfolio manager of four investment partnerships, two of which focus significant elements of their investment strategy on investing in community banks. In addition, Mr. Hopkins is responsible for the firm’s corporate development efforts, including mergers and acquisitions, joint ventures and capital raising. Mr. Hopkins provides the board with a background in corporate finance, investment decision making, capital markets and strategic decision-making.

• Michael Baker

  
  Director since 2004 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. Baker is a native of Wheeling, West Virginia, graduated from West Liberty State College in 1979, with a Bachelor of Science degree in Business Administration and with a specialty in Business Management.  He worked for the former Ram Construction Company of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, as a Project Manager until February 1985.  In June 1985, along with a partner, he founded the Cast and Baker Corporation, a site development, excavating, and general contracting company located in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.  Mr. Baker is also actively involved in the management of several other companies including President of Justus, Inc., a real estate development group; Signature Air Corp., an aircraft charter company; and Centre City Industrial Park, a real estate management group.  Mr. Baker is an active member of St. Michael Parish.

• Nick Sparachane

  
  Director since 2004 (MSFS, MSBC) Mr. Sparachane is a native of Wheeling, WV, serves as Partner/Owner of USI Insurance, one of the nation’s leading insurance firms. He also serves as Vice-Chairman and owner of Undo’s Family Restaurants which operates 3 locations in the Upper Ohio Valley area. In 2020 he opened the Alpha Tavern along with 2 others. He is a partner in the Justus Development Group, and Centre City Industrial Park, as well as President of Sparachane Realty.  He also completed an 8-year term as Mayor of the City of Wheeling and has been active in the community serving on numerous Boards including Wheeling Hospital, the Ohio Valley Construction Employers Council, RED and several bank boards prior to Main Street Bank’s Board of Directors.